PLEASE NOTE: the following are the opinions of the Dolly Insider. END NOTE
February 12, 2016, Groove Inc. made an announcement about authorized retailers of their Pullip brand of dolls.
Also included in this announcement was the authorized retailers list for the Pullip My Melody x Hen-Nako which will be making her debut outside of Japan February 2016.
Groove concluded their announcement with a short list of unauthorized retailers who buyers should stay clear of.
It’s Not Unusual
It’s not unusual for companies to provide their customers with a list of authorized retailers or distributors of their products or services.
Apple has an authorized reseller list.
Most customers welcome such a list because the information helps with deciding on where to purchase a product or service.
More Questions Than Answers
While the alert was helpful unfortunately it left collectors with more questions than answers.
And we found it all a bit strange.
Groove starts out by telling fans what they should expect when purchasing dolls from unauthorized retailers:
Then Groove provides a list of authorized retailers but here is where the confusion and strangeness begins.
They only provide a list of shops who are authorized by Sanrio Co., Ltd. to sell Pullip My Melody x Hen-Nako.
Why didn’t they provide a list of all the authorized Pullip retailers not just the ones approved by Sanrio Co., Ltd.?
Does this mean the other Pullip dolls are not at risk of being counterfeit?
Strangeness Continues
Another bit of strangeness is this:
Their statement makes it tough for you to sell your used doll on sites like eBay, Craigslist, Live Journal etc. because now buyers have this uncertainty playing in their heads.
Imagine you decide to sell your gently used doll because you no longer can care for her and you list her on eBay in the hopes of finding her a new home but now with Groove’s warning buyers are more likely not to buy your doll because you are not an authorized retailer.
Do you think Groove’s warning will have an effect on the sale of your doll?
Then Things Get Messy
The announcement gets a bit messy & a bit tacky.
Groove states:
Groove publicly ousts 3 retailers, implying that you should not purchase your dolls from these shops.
- Why did they pick these 3 shops?
- Why didn’t Groove notify the shops about this issue before making this public announcement?
- Who thought it was a good idea to blatantly blast these shops publicly? Now the perception of these retailers has changed.
- Why didn’t Groove investigate and give the Pullip collectors evidence of wrongdoing?
It sure would have made things less confusing.
Their Side of the Story
We were in touch with 2 of the 3 shops to get their side of the story and they stated the following:
These stores may not purchase directly through Groove but according to them, their dolls come from authorized retailers.
It is possible to be a retailer of Pullip and not purchase directly through Groove Inc.
For example, you can get a wholesale account from Hobby Link Japan, an authorized retailer of Pullip dolls and you can get a wholesale account with Entertainment Earth who also sells Pullip dolls.
Warnings & Dolls
1/2 kudos goes to Groove Inc. for making an attempt to create an authorize retailer list.
But they may have done more harm than good.
What are your thoughts about the consumer alert?
If the issue is resolved in favor of the 3 “unauthorized retailers” will you still have doubts on whether to purchase from them?
Where you a victim of unauthorized retailers? If so, please share your experience.
If you’re a shopper of 1 of the “unauthorized retailers” please share your experience and support. We’d like to hear from you.
Share your thoughts on the Groove Inc.’s Consumer Alert: Authorized Retailer matter. Let us know in the comment box below.
PLEASE NOTE: the following were the opinions of the Dolly Insider. END NOTE
Hi. I think Groove went about it a little weird, but overall I do not see a problem with it. Besides dolls, I also collect nendoroids and other figures. It is well known already among figure collectors that ebay, Amazon, etc. are full of counterfeits/ bootlegs and recasts. There are so many that people do tend to avoid them because of this, but I sell things on ebay all the time and have no trouble. Experienced collectors know what to look for, but it’s nice for new buyers to be warned about it as many have been tricked in their first purchases from those sites and often don’t realize it until several months later when it’s too late to get their money back.
As for the 3 retailers they ousted, I understand what you mean. But the fact the two sources mention things like “80% come from known retailers” and have dolls sourced from different parts of the world and pre-owned, etc. means that they cannot guarantee the 100% authenticity of all of their stock. This may be causing problems for Groove, who may be getting contacted about issues with dolls from these shops. I have seen Issues like this in the figure collecting world as well. Groove may be posting the list as a way to protect themselves in case more issues arise to show that they are not responsible.
Hello Tai,
I understand what you mean about fake figures on eBay.
It has gotten so out of hand and Amazon is becoming just as bad 🙁
Indeed Groove has a right to protect their brand & future responsibilities.
With the figure companies, when they issue fake warnings it educates new & seasoned collectors.
Good Smile Company does this extremely well and they also provide consumers with a list of authorize retailers and distributors of their products.
Groove’s warning about authorize & unauthorized retailers, to me, came across as very strict.
I don’t think they honestly know who is selling their products.
The alert would have had a greater impact had they sited
or simply provided us with a comprehensive authorized retailer list instead of pointing fingers without providing a better explanation.
fake Pullips
Groove also mentioned a warranty and post-sale care . . . I wonder if that was the main focus of their alert?
I’m certainly interested in learning more about the warranty & post-sale care.
Right now I’m a bit confused because Groove USA gives you 3 days to return or exchange a doll due to manufacture defect and 30 days for returns. . . so how does the Groove factory warranty work exactly?
Thanks Tai for taking the time to share your thoughts on Groove’s Consumer Alert.
The Pullip community needs something fun and uplifting . . . I wonder what can be done to get collectors back on track 🙂
I personally think toy Malaysia has excellent customer service. In fact I recommend them. They gave me a full refund on a doll that was super limited when groove released more at lower price…I was Astonished. That means a lot to me. I will purchase from them again. This announcement has not dissuade me in any negative way.
Hello Jane,
Thank you for taking the time to share your shopping experience with Toy Malaysia.
It is good to hear that the Consumer Alert has not persuaded you to stop shopping with Toy Malaysia.
I don’t think Dolls.moe or Toy Malaysia set out to harm any consumers/collectors.
And I understand Groove Inc. wanting to protect their brand.
It’s unfortunate that it all had to play out the way it has – so publicly.
Thanks again Jane for stopping by and sharing your experience 🙂
Groove’s alert is so puzzling. I have ordered dolls from two of the three companies that are on their “unauthorized retailers” list, Toy Malaysia and Dolls.Moe, and in my experience they seem completetely valid. I have been particularly happy about the European retailer – and they are scarce – Dolls.Moe, whose products and customer service have never been less than perfect. Personally, I don’t care if the retailers haven’t bought straight from Groove, but what I do care is the authenticity and the quality of the product, along with customer service. I’m sorry, but I’m just not buying Groove’s alert regarding the named retailers, not without further proofs.
Hello Virvatulia,
I am like you, I want proof or a better explanation on the consumer alert.
It’s a mystery as to why they decided to issue this alert now.
We’re almost approaching a week and still no clarification.
Hopefully, Groove will clarify things soon.
Thank you for sharing your experience with both Dolls.Moe and Toy Malaysia and for sharing your thoughts about Groove Inc’s consumer alert.
P.S. Cute dolly images by the way 🙂
The whole thing seems very strange and confusing. There was a discussion on another blog that suggested maybe it was some sort of licensing issue with the My Melody Pullip in particular but the way Groove worded their “reason”, it kind of sounds like all Pullips from those three retailers. I also assumed they were talking about brand new Pullips …
I’d be interested to see if there is anymore explanation from Groove on this.
Hi Alasse Carnesir,
I agree it is all too “strange and confusing”
The My Melody Sanrio licensing sounds like a nice theory but I’m not totally convince, yet.
Had they stopped at the authorized retailers, it would have made sense.
Groove’s alert feels like one of those True/False test you take in school.
If any part of the question is false, then the entire statement is false but just because part of a statement is true doesn’t necessarily make the entire statement true –Test Taking Tips
It would be nice and I believe, in Groove’s best interest, to offer fans some type of explanation on why they posted this alert in the first place and why they picked those 3 stores.
This is an unfortunate event for the Pullip community.
It was brought to our attention that Groove “borrowed” the consumer alert from Yamaha. That could explain why it doesn’t feel right.
*Yamaha source provided by TM Customer
Hello,
When I saw this alert on Groove’s blog I was very shocked because I’ve actually buy my Isul The Little Prince on Toy Malaysia (thanks to you BTW so thank you very very very much!) and I have got no problem with them! No defective product or pirated account so… I don’t understand why Groove published that list which seems very offensive for me.
It’s just like eBay! When I can’t find a doll on an official website I’m more than happy to find my dream doll here! That way I’ve got many pre-owned or new (in still sealed boxes!) pullip : Io, Ala, China China, Lunatic Queen, Barasuishou, Cornice and Nella Retro Memory and they all were on a very good condition so no! I’m not agree to castigate eBay or Amazon like that! All the retailers are not criminals who only think about making profit upon the naivety of people!
Sure it’s a good things to have a list of authorized retailers. This way we are sure that the product is a authentic one but in my opinion it’s very harmful to castigate in such a rude way other websites.
Nicely said Anne-Sophie.
I understanding what Groove was “trying” to do with their alert but they failed in the execution.
Groove Inc “copied” the text from Yamaha* and because they didn’t grasp what Yamaha was truly doing with the unauthorized list, Groove’s alert failed to informed and instead confused the fans.
I wasn’t aware that Groove Inc. offered a warranty for their dolls. I wonder if it is a lifetime warranty?
Had Groove Inc. established “buy from us directly” retailer relationships from the start, they wouldn’t have had to issue this bizarre and strangely timed consumer alert.
Groove’s alert doesn’t hold up against facts either, here’s why, posted on Pullip.Asia, an authorized retailer of Groove Inc products, a person/business can get an active wholesaler account with them (pullip.asia/wholesale) page removed – link no longer active .
Since that seller is not buying “directly” from Groove does this mean the seller should be placed on the unauthorized list?
According to Groove’s consumer alert, they should be (unless Pullip.Asia is in fact Groove Inc. of Singapore & Malaysia).
This whole event doesn’t feel right at all. As Judge Judy says “don’t pee on my leg and tell me it’s raining”
I can’t understand why Groove Inc. picked those 3 shops out of all the shops to feature on this list.
There aren’t a lot of shops selling Pullip but you can find a few and some of them appear to be offering Pullip dolls like the “3” shops on the list.
Why weren’t these other shops included?
Thank you Anne-Sophie for sharing your experience with Toy Malaysia & for sharing your thoughts about Groove Inc’s consumer alert.
*Yamaha source provided by TM Customer, Thanks
Just today I realized that Dolls.moe is selling Angelgate dolls, which to my knowledge are illegal recasts of Pullip dolls. That might, or might not, be part of the reason why Dolls.moe is on Groove’s blacklist – I wouldn’t be surprised. I myself will reconsider next time whether I really want to order from them, since I don’t want to support such business.
Hey Virvatulia,
Thanks for the Dolls.moe update.
Oh, I remember Angelgate dolls.
I can’t believe Angelgate dolls are still around.
I understand your concerns on whether to purchase from a store that sells recast/fake dolls.
When shopping online we always have to be aware/alert of fakes.
It’s a sad side effect of this hobby.
~Kat
Following the fans concerns we have completely stopped selling Angelgates. Also, we were offered by Groove to buy directly from them, and we do right now, with much more better prices than before.
Hi dolls.moe,
That is great news to hear! 🙂
It seems everything worked out in the end.
Thanks for taking the time to update us all!
~Kat
@dollface Actually we got an offer of buying directly from Groove US few months ago, we were buying from AGA before, so it makes even more sense to stop it, prices are really good.
I do however bring some old model dolls from my Japan trips, like Prunella and such. I will try to ask the manager at Groove US to get us out of the list, though since US branch and Japan branch have separate managements, I don’t know if it is going to work out.
Hopefully by working with Groove you’ll be able to get your name of the list soon 🙂
~Kat